Trying to Appeal to Everyone — and Ending Up Meaning Nothing
- Kwik Branding
- Jan 21
- 5 min read
In the pursuit of pleasing everyone, brands often lose the only thing that ever made them matter — point of view.
📖 Contents
The Reality Check: The Age of Bland Brilliance
We live in a world of optimized neutrality.Every brand wants to be inclusive, palatable, “relatable.” Every founder wants to sound balanced, safe, likable.
But in the process, something vital gets stripped away — edge.
Scroll through any social platform and you’ll find an endless feed of perfect sameness:A thousand coaches teaching “authentic leadership.”
A hundred startups selling “human-first” tech. A million captions saying “we’re passionate about innovation.”
It’s all polished, positive, and painfully predictable.
The modern brand voice has become a corporate beige — inoffensive to everyone, unforgettable to everyone else.
Trying to resonate with everyone is the fastest way to disappear into noise.
Because influence isn’t built on consensus. It’s built on conviction.
The Shift: From Likability to Distinctiveness
The most trusted brands aren’t the ones everyone loves — they’re the ones people remember.
Apple was once ridiculed for being “too expensive.”
Patagonia was dismissed as “too activist.”
Netflix was told subscription models would never scale.
Every one of them chose to sound like themselves — not like the category.
In psychology, this is called the Distinctiveness Effect — our brains remember what breaks pattern, not what blends in. Sameness feels safe. But it’s also invisible.
When a brand tries to appeal to everyone, it unconsciously trains the audience to forget it.
When it dares to stand for something — even at the risk of being disliked — it becomes magnetic.
You don’t need universal approval. You need emotional recognition.
The Illusion of Relatability
“Relatable” has become the new currency of digital branding. We want founders who “feel human,” companies that “talk like friends,” brands that “speak our language.”
But in trying to sound human, most end up sounding algorithmic — perfectly polite, emotionally hollow.
Because real relatability doesn’t come from saying what people like.It comes from saying what they feel but rarely hear out loud.
Think of how Nike’s “Believe in something, even if it means sacrificing everything” polarised audiences. Or how Dove’s “Real Beauty” challenged beauty norms instead of flattering them.Those campaigns didn’t play safe — they hit a nerve.
Relatability built on risk, not repetition, is what creates resonance.
The Emotional Cost of Playing Safe
Playing it safe looks smart on a spreadsheet. No controversy. No backlash. No risk.
But there’s a hidden cost — emotional invisibility.
The audience doesn’t engage with neutrality; they engage with energy. When your voice loses tension, your brand loses traction.
A brand that never offends will also never inspire. A leader who never takes a stance will never move hearts.
Because trust doesn’t come from balance — it comes from boldness. From being brave enough to be specific.
The moment you stop evoking reaction, you stop evoking relevance.
But here’s the paradox — the safer you sound, the faster you vanish.
The Psychology Behind It: Cognitive Dissonance and the Comfort Trap
Our brains are wired for belonging. We seek approval, avoid rejection, and interpret safety as success. That’s why brands fear being “too niche” — they equate narrowness with limitation.
But neuroscience tells a different story.Cognitive dissonance — that slight discomfort when confronted with a strong opinion — actually deepens memory. We remember the things that challenge our assumptions, not the ones that confirm them.
That’s why humor lands. Why protest art lingers. Why contrarian founders build cult followings.
A little friction, handled with clarity, doesn’t alienate — it anchors.It tells people: This brand knows who it is, even if you don’t agree.
The Identity Trap: Confusing Adaptability with Authenticity
Many leaders think being flexible means being relevant. But there’s a difference between evolving and erasing yourself.
Adaptability is changing your form to fit your future. Appeasement is changing your form to fit everyone else’s expectations.
When you try to appeal to every audience, you lose coherence. When you hold a core truth steady and evolve around it, you gain loyalty.
Think of Hermès — their designs evolve every year, but the principle doesn’t: time, patience, permanence. Or Tesla — loved and hated in equal measure, but never mistaken for anything else.
Authenticity isn’t a tone. It’s alignment between your choices and your truth.
The Case of the “Almost” Brand
Every founder has seen one: the startup that looks polished, sounds smart, has all the right words — and still fails to land.
They say everything the market expects — but nothing the market remembers. They blend in too well.
That’s the curse of the Almost Brand: technically flawless, emotionally flat.
No contradictions. No controversy. No clear stance.Just a smooth hum of self-approval.
The result? No one disagrees — but no one cares either.
The Courage to Polarize
The word polarize has been demonized. But in reality, it’s just proof of definition. If you’re clear enough to attract, you’ll automatically repel.
And that’s a good thing.
Because clarity creates contrast — and contrast creates connection.
Great brands embrace that tension. They know that influence isn’t about winning over everyone; it’s about finding your people and giving them something to believe in.
Meaning requires exclusion. If everyone can own your story, no one will remember it’s yours.
Practical Reflections
Specificity builds gravity. The narrower your stance, the deeper your influence.
Friction builds memorability. Comfort creates forgettability.
Authenticity isn’t about being liked. It’s about being understood.
If your voice doesn’t divide opinion, it’s probably dissolving into the crowd.
The Leaders Who Got It Right
Ben & Jerry’s didn’t become beloved by playing neutral; they took political stands most consumer brands avoided.
Rihanna’s Fenty didn’t just sell makeup; it redefined beauty inclusivity through unapologetic representation.
None of these decisions were safe. All of them were sincere.
And sincerity, when expressed fearlessly, scales faster than strategy.
The Final Thought
Appealing to everyone is a seductive idea — it promises scale, approval, and peace. But peace built on politeness is fragile.
Because influence isn’t found in agreement; it’s found in alignment. In choosing to mean something so clearly that misunderstanding becomes part of the brand.
The world doesn’t need more agreeable voices. It needs more voices unafraid to sound like themselves.
In the end, it’s simple: You can be universal, or you can be unforgettable. You rarely get to be both.
Comments